Composition: In the frame I cropped out some of the foreground (the bottom of the fireplace) and only showed a little background in order to emphasize the detail in the woodwork. The lighting in the photograph is mostly natural, which created defining lines within the subject and in turn made the image more dramatic.
Method: I took the photograph at a close range in order to see the detail of the wood that would otherwise be overlooked. This photograph was taken with the potential of being used for an advertisement, which inspired me to capture the fireplace in a new way.
Context: If this image was in color I could see it being in a magazine like Better Home and Garden. However, as a black and white photograph I think it stands more as a fine art work opposed to commercial photography.
Interpretation: Mostly everyone agreed that if this image was in color it would be more successful for being a magazine advertisement. The way it stands now reads more as fine art because of the abstraction of the lighting/shapes.
Evaluation: Although in black and white it makes the image more abstract, the lighting of this photograph works for an ad. The lighting emphasizes the detail of the woodwork.
Extension: This image is one of a series of a kitchen. If the assignment was more specific, I would have printed a mini series to show the overall view of the kitchen and then photographs like the one above to show detail of the work.
Composition: I think this photograph has a lot of visual design elements. One of the reasons this image is attractive is because of the balance of the sky with the ground and the lighting of the memorial. The overall lighting (natural from the sky, artificial from the memorial) and the silhouettes create emphasis on the building.
Method: Whenever I try to capture the beauty and history of Washington, DC the images usually result with the same appearance as anyone else taking travel photographs. People usually end up being the focal point. What set this photograph a part from those was the lighting. I also tried to capture the photograph at an angle that was not straight on, as that is usually when the people are most visible. The time of day ended up being key for this shot. Not only was it beneficial for the lighting, but it was also a time in which there were not a lot of tourists.
Context: As soon as I saw this image on my camera I thought it would make a good postcard. Looking around DC there are a lot of postcards with the memorials at night. I think the photograph I took is different in that this was not taken at night, but rather dusk. I enjoy the coloring and that a slight sunset can be seen at the left horizon line.
Interpretation: Everyone saw this as a postcard, but only as a postcard image, not an actual postcard.
Evaluation: The class thought this would be more successful if there wasn't so much black in the foreground, some found it to be distracting. Others thought it would look more like a postcard if there was text.
Extension: It would be fun to try to take more travel photographs and attempt to make them appear as postcards. I think the interesting thing about postcards is how commercial "common" places look. In this case, the Lincoln Memorial is probably one of the most visited and photographed places in DC, yet not every photograph of it looks like a postcard.
Composition: The perspective and point of view are important for the concept of this photograph. In addition, the cropping is also important in order to keep out distracting elements. Both enforce the commercial appearance of the photograph, which is also important for the concept.
Method: This image somewhat pokes fun at commercial photography and how advertising can make just about anything seem desirable. In this case I used cafeteria food in a way that would make it appear to be more appetizing than it really is. It was important to crop out the background so that the focus was more on the food than the environment of the cafeteria. Other images revealed the more grotesque perception of the food while this image made it more attractive.
Context: I think this image deals with the social construction of advertisement and the art of it. Through advertising and art anything can appear different than it is. It will be interesting to see how people react to this based on the appeal it has although the content is not anything special.
Interpretation: Few people commented on this photograph, but those that did said that it was not very commercial.
Evaluation: People that commented on this photograph did not care for the composition (the fork and the thing "being blurred in the top right corner") and thought it had a yellow tint. While those observations were viewed as unsuccessful, I think that those elements add to the point of the photograph.
Extension: As it stands, based off of people's reaction, in order to make this piece more successful I would try to retake the shot and use more studio lighting instead of the cafeteria lighting. This might help make it read as more commercial.
Composition: Originally this photograph was simple, with little background information because I wanted to photoshop it to have a completely different background. The framing of this edited image is the same as the original photograph.
Method: While I was photographing the shoe, I was thinking about how to frame it so that I could later edit in the text. My goal was to make the photograph look unrealistic and have a copy and pasted appearance, the way a lot of advertisements look. I chose the background color to contrast the shoe and give the overall image a commercial appeal.
Context: I used the recognizable slogan, "Just Do It", with a Nike shoe to make viewers associate my photograph with a Nike advertisement. Although a few things are different, the addition of "Already" and the display of the Nike swoosh, overall I think the feel of the photograph is a Nike advertisement.
Interpretation: This photograph was interpreted as a Nike advertisement. Overall people thought it was successful in having the copy and paste appearance.
Evaluation: The addition of "already" makes the photograph more original than only using the "Just Do It" slogan. Someone said that changing the background color would help make it look more commercial.
Extension: Using the focus of advertisements and slogans, I could see this image being a piece of a project that explored the similarities in completely opposite companies selling different products- continuing the play on slogans and products.